Mayoral Election: Could London's Rail Services Become Part of TfL?

By BethPH Last edited 146 months ago
Mayoral Election: Could London's Rail Services Become Part of TfL?

Earlier this month, Boris Johnson set out his plans to bring London's rail services under the control of City Hall and TfL in a bid to improve London's transport.

Mainline rail routes into London are currently franchised to private companies with varying degrees of customer service, timeliness and efficiency and the mayor believes he can do a better job. A recent Telegraph poll suggests that over 75% of other people think he can do a better job too. So does Ken Livingstone, though obviously he's planning in terms of himself being mayor rather than Boris. Let's take a look at their plans for devolution of rail franchises in London:

Under Boris Johnson

  • A turn up and go frequency of at least four trains an hour throughout the week
  • Improved security with networked CCTV and help points at all stations, plus improved lighting and more stations gated to reduce anti-social behaviour.
  • Improved stations by deep cleaning and refurbishing.
  • Visible staff presence across the network throughout the day, offering proactive assistance to customers.
  • Visual and public address systems providing real time service information supported by the best and most comprehensive online and mobile enabled journey planning system anywhere in the world.
  • High quality cycle parking facilities to promote cycling as a means of access to stations.

Under Ken Livingstone

  • All stations will receive a frequency of service of at least four trains per hour throughout the week.
  • All stations deep cleaned and meeting a standard of cleanliness that is equivalent to that currently maintained by the Overground.
  • Improving passenger safety by ensuring that stations are staffed at all times that services are running and that staff are visible and available to customers, offering them assistance on a proactive basis whenever possible.
  • All stations will be equipped with Help Points on every platform to enable customers to request information or assistance if they need it.
  • All stations will be equipped with state of the art visual and aural customer information systems on platforms and in entrance areas/ticket halls that provide customers with real time information on the train service provided.
  • All stations will have cycle parking facilities that match TfL’s quantitative and qualitative standard in this area, so that it is easier for commuters to travel the last mile home by bike.
  • Making it easier for passengers with mobility problems to use the train with more step-free access at stations.
  • Fares that are consistent with Tube fares, ensuring that no suburban rail passengers are worse off and many benefit from Ken’s Fare Deal policy of a 7% fares cut, saving the average Londoner £1000 over the next four years.

To be honest, there's nothing that surprising in either of those proposals. It's not rocket science to deduce that rail users would quite like clean, safe trains and stations, frequent trains and up-to-date information without having to rely on Twitter. The cycle parking is a biggie too; the profile of cycling and its subsequent politicisation has increased dramatically in the last year or so and a rusty railing to chain one's bike to outside a station is no longer acceptable. 853 blog recently (and reluctantly) let the cat out of the bag about the vastly improved cycle parking at North Greenwich.

Southeastern and West Anglia have been identified as prime candidates for devolution. The former has been plagued by complaints about poor services, ranging from missing stations to an apparent inability to run trains in either hot or cold weather.

Can TfL afford to run suburban rail services? According to Boris Johnson's office, the £100m savings made over 20 years by devolution would enable the refurbishment of 100 stations. But as we know, the mayor is committed to further fare increases which could mean unhappy passengers seeing higher fares for an unimproved service before things reach London Overground standards. Ken Livingstone has pledged a 7% cut in fares which will obviously win him some friends among commuters but will he be able to provide the investment necessary for future infrastructure costs? Either way, Londoners will want to see those pre-election promises come to fruition.

Photo by Nick Holdstock

Last Updated 24 February 2012