Hitchens Hobby Horse: Reunify The Parthenon Sculptures

Lindsey
By Lindsey Last edited 107 months ago
Hitchens Hobby Horse: Reunify The Parthenon Sculptures

parthenon_dd.jpg
By D I C K S D A I L Y via the Londonist Flickrpool
It's difficult for anyone to visit the Duveen Galleries at the British Museum and not be both impressed and troubled by the impressive recreation of the Parthenon through the assemblage of the sculptures and fragments of frieze Lord Elgin removed from Athens in the early 19th century. Obtained with imperialist arrogance and intended for ill-advised interior decoration they were subsequently acquired by Parliament and gifted to the British Museum. Christopher Hitchens has spikily revived the argument that it's time to restore the 'borrowed' treasure to its original home so the world can appreciate the ancient work of art as "more than the mere sum of its parts". His New York Times opinion piece prompted by the opening - at last - of Athens' stunning looking, state of the art New Acropolis Museum and the imminent publication of his book on the subject, strongly suggest that now museums in Palermo, the Vatican and Heidelberg have returned chunks from their collections to Athens, its high time the BM followed suit.

However they were acquired, the Parthenon sculptures are a jewel in the British Museum's crown and debate has long ranged over the ethical, cultural and legal aspects of keeping them in the UK and the bizarrely grotesque status quo of having a head over here and a torso over there. Hitchens' new book will undoubtedly kick the conversation open again with interminable wrangles ensuing. Just imagine though, the Duveen Galleries standing empty - what would you like to see fill them?

Last Updated 19 June 2009

M@

Yeah, I often wonder, how many people really do go to the British Museum specifically to see the Elgin Marbles? Would the crowds stop flocking without them? I reckon the vast majority of folk who visit won't have even heard of the Marbles and are going just because it's one of the most famous museums in the world.

gothictemplar

The BM has lost the argument, and its defence of the indefensible becomes ever more desperate. I'm sure M@ is right, and that very few people visit the BM just to see the Marbles. There must be any number of artefacts sitting in the BM's basement that could be put in their place, and the gallery would make a good space for special exhibitions. Time for the BM trustees to wake up and smell the coffee.