Lane Rental Scheme To Combat Roadworks

Photo by Stew Dean.

What do the numbers 38, 100 and one billion have in common? They all factor into the cost to London of roadworks with 100 utility companies digging up the roads causing 38% of traffic delays which costs the city £1 billion in economic disruption. It’s rather a lot, especially with the 2012 Olympics bearing down on us bringing its own transport issues.

London mayor Boris Johnson has thrown in his lot with the borough chiefs and other business leaders to get the government to approve a lane rental scheme which aims to incentivise utility companies to complete work faster. Under the proposal, companies wanting to dig up the roads would pay rent for the period of time they’re at work so it’s in their interests to cut down the tea breaks and crack on with digging or face a hefty bill. But why should we make things easier for motorists, we hear you cry, and we refer you back to the first paragraph of this article: £1 billion. So it’s not just about creating crater-free roads to zip about on, but to cut down the wasted time for everyone, from the delayed buses to the missed deliveries to the companies who move out of London. And that’s not to mention the environmental benefit of decreasing emissions caused by congestion.

Under the mayor’s Code of Conduct for Roadworks, utility companies are supposed to provide more information about the reason for any delays, but that doesn’t stop them being delays in the first place and trying to persuade companies to coordinate roadworks has the distinct feeling of herding cats to it. The lane rental scheme could mean those delays disappear as utility companies find themselves handing over their hard-earned profits in rent and fines.

In the mayor’s transport manifesto, he put commuters and improving traffic flow at the top of his list of pledges:  ‘Most Londoners would agree that there is nothing more frustrating than driving past a hole in the road with no obvious sign of work taking place. Or seeing the same roads dug up time and again. I will be tougher with utility companies, and I will call for the government to finally give the mayor the power to fine utility companies who cause delays.’ But even Boris admitted earlier this year that it was proving to be a much tougher proposition than he’d anticipated.

So what are they waiting for? The government to start a consultation for one – it was meant to begin in July this year. And as we all know, such things can move slower than, well, a very slow moving thing indeed so to try and give the government a jump start, Boris Johnson is seeking the opinion of Londoners on the www.london.gov.uk website where we can vote in a handy little poll so if you want to see those three numbers at the top looking a lot lower, put your vote in.

  • Dave

    “But why should we make things easier for motorists, we hear you cry…”

    Well this doesn’t exclusively affect motorists anyway. Cyclists have to swerve out of cycle lanes to avoid roadworks. Buses have to pull out of bus lanes. I’ve lost count of the number of times that I, as a pedestrian, have been prevented from crossing the road by roadworks.

    All road-users are negatively affected by poorly-planned roadworks, so anything that mitigates this should be welcome.

  • Dave

    “But why should we make things easier for motorists, we hear you cry…”

    Well this doesn’t exclusively affect motorists anyway. Cyclists have to swerve out of cycle lanes to avoid roadworks. Buses have to pull out of bus lanes. I’ve lost count of the number of times that I, as a pedestrian, have been prevented from crossing the road by roadworks.

    All road-users are negatively affected by poorly-planned roadworks, so anything that mitigates this should be welcome.

  • http://twitter.com/steinsky Joe Dunckley

    Indeed. Pedestrians seem to get the worst treatment — where is the mayor’s campaign for replacement crossings when roadworks switch off the lights? And this initiative should be coupled with a £1 million tax on “cyclists dismount” signs.

    The £billion figure is of course utter bollocks, though. Leaving aside the fact that it’s simply not possible to estimate such complicated effects (but it’s vital to include a meaningless big number if you want your press release picked up), London’s road transport demand is so elastic that newly created road capacity will always be quickly snapped up. The vast latent demand means that any and every attempt to tackle congestion in densely populated cities will always be doomed to fail. As every attempt to tackle congestion in London shows. And yet people still fall for every new press release that claims the problem will be solved…

  • http://twitter.com/steinsky Joe Dunckley

    Indeed. Pedestrians seem to get the worst treatment — where is the mayor’s campaign for replacement crossings when roadworks switch off the lights? And this initiative should be coupled with a £1 million tax on “cyclists dismount” signs.

    The £billion figure is of course utter bollocks, though. Leaving aside the fact that it’s simply not possible to estimate such complicated effects (but it’s vital to include a meaningless big number if you want your press release picked up), London’s road transport demand is so elastic that newly created road capacity will always be quickly snapped up. The vast latent demand means that any and every attempt to tackle congestion in densely populated cities will always be doomed to fail. As every attempt to tackle congestion in London shows. And yet people still fall for every new press release that claims the problem will be solved…

  • Stew Dean

    Pssst. My photo link should be to http://www.flickr.com/photos/stewdean/ Ta.

  • Stew Dean

    Pssst. My photo link should be to http://www.flickr.com/photos/stewdean/ Ta.

  • Beth Torr

    Apologies, Stew – I put the link on but we’ve just moved to a new system and it fell off again.

    @Dave – I absolutely agree but it seems every time I write about something which affects road users in general the ‘all motorists are evil’ brigade pop up.

  • http://oxocubeeditorial.blogspot.com Beth Torr

    Apologies, Stew – I put the link on but we’ve just moved to a new system and it fell off again.

    @Dave – I absolutely agree but it seems every time I write about something which affects road users in general the ‘all motorists are evil’ brigade pop up.

  • Debg

    Can we also please put this into perspective whilst still acknowledging the enormity of the problem. The article quotes 38% of of delays caused by roadworks by utilities. This is not true. TfL’s own report shows a figure of 38%, 19% caused by utility works which are essential to keep London’s infrastructure safe and reliable and 19% caused by authority works. If we truly want to make an impact, then the same conditions, charges and incentives should also be applied to TfL.

  • Debg

    Can we also please put this into perspective whilst still acknowledging the enormity of the problem. The article quotes 38% of of delays caused by roadworks by utilities. This is not true. TfL’s own report shows a figure of 38%, 19% caused by utility works which are essential to keep London’s infrastructure safe and reliable and 19% caused by authority works. If we truly want to make an impact, then the same conditions, charges and incentives should also be applied to TfL.