New Restaurant Review: Redhook

4814465025_f60d16c7c3_m.jpg
Photography by Chris Osburn

Newly opened in Farringdon where the Frenchily swish St Germain brasserie used to be, Redhook is a seafood and steak resto owned by the Rushmore group (Milk & Honey, Giant Robot and The East Room). With its cushy seats and divine lighting, this surf-n-turfer’s eclectic dining area is a pleasant enough space to find yourself settling in for a nice meal. We just wish our meal there last night had been a lot nicer.

Chuffed as we were to have received an invitation to give the menu a go by the Redhook folks, unfortunately we can’t return the favour with a glowing review. Despite large portions and a delectably perusable menu, we felt prices were too high and quality was somewhat questionable (gritty razor clams were a bummer). The steaks (we tried the New York strip loin and the Wagyu fillet) were okay, we suppose. But, we know better beef splendour can be obtained in London at equal or less expensive.

There were elements of our dining experience that we liked. The king crab legs were gorgeous. And we must note that Redhook’s wine list is pretty fab (especially if you like American wines) – we very much enjoyed our Au Bon Climat ’06 Chardonnay (£55 for a bottle). As for service, it was a bit wonky and uncertain but we believe they meant well. Aside from that, we don’t much see the point of this noob and reckon there are myriad better dining options nearby.

Redhook is located at 89 Turnmill Street (EC1M 5QU). Check the restaurant out online at redhooklondon.com.

  • http://undefined AndrewS

    It doesn’t sound like it’s improved significantly since its soft launch earlier this month, which was reviewed in the Cheese and Biscuits blog.

  • http://www.tikichris.com Chris Osburn

    Yeah, I saw the C&B review. Looks like Mr Pople’s experience was similar to mine. I don’t always agree with him but always value and respect his judgement.

    Redhook has a few good things going for it but, considering the local competition at the same and lower price level, there’s not much reason to visit. Probably wouldn’t be a bad place to pop in for a glass of wine or a cocktail.

  • http://clubtwilight.ru John Hale

    Looks really tasty. But quite expensive for poor poor student:)

  • Fran1976

    Dinner with my girlfriend last week – atmosphere, decor, food, drinks, all spot on, seems to have stepped up a notch or two from earlier experiences. Live just round the corner and will definitely be checking it out sometime soon again.

  • tikichris

    Fran1976,

    Thanks for your update! We’re always keen to receive readers’ opinion about the places we review.

    Chris

  • Andycop1

    I went to Redhook on Friday evening with my partner and my parents.  My first impressions were positive as the decor was superb and there was nice, lively atmosphere; without it being too loud.  My first impressions were going to be challenged througout the course of the evening.
     
    We had two waiters on the evening, I can’t recall their names so will refer to them as Chalk and Cheese for the duration of this review.  Chalk was a most friendly, helpful chap from Leeds, Cheese was an aloof, bordering on arrogant, unhelpful chap with a questionable goatee.  From where Cheese hails I have no idea, as any attempt at small talk during ordering and later complaining was met with short shrift.
     
    The food was a mixed bag, for starters I had the Soft Shell Crab Tempura, the Tempura was thicker than I have come to expect.  The Crab once I got to it was fresh with the right texture, but lacked seasoning.  My partner went for the Crab Linguine, it was superb, rich, garlicky with a nice amount of crab, parsley and chill.  Both my parents went for the Oysters, Dad, raw with a Red Wine Vinegar and Shallot dressing and Mum, grilled with Parmesan and black pepper.  Dads Oysters had that milky look and were as big as Clams (some of the smallest I have ever seen), my Dad, not one to mince words stated they were the first Oysters he had ever tasted that didn’t taste of the sea.   The grilled Oysters were said to be’ pretty uninspiring’.  When the waiter (Cheese) asked how the starters were I mentioned the above, he stated he was sorry and then just carried on being aloof.  Being a typically English complainer (rubbish) I left it at that.
     
    The mains were on the whole a triumph. my partner went for the Scallops with Chorizo, My Mum the Sea Bass, both were cooked to perfection and both of them waxed lyrical about their choices.  Dad and I ordered the British Surf & Turf, which consisted of  Sirloin Steak and two Langoustines.  The steak was superb, seasoned to perfection with a wonderful texture.  The Langoustines were overcooked, although strangely enough to varying degress, my first one was just overcooked the second one was like floury mush.  My Dad’s were by all acounts the same.  For sides we had Goose fat Chips and the Spring greens, both were very well cooked and a joy to eat.  We also ordered the Lentils & Pancetta, which they forgot to bring.
     
    When the bill arrived (£310 for four, with two bottles of the cheaper wine), the waiter asked how we enjoyed it, when I started to try and explain that on the whole the mains were great, BUT the Langoustines were like mush and he forgot to bring the Lentils, he again apologised quite tersly and proceeded to carry on along his way.  Like I said earlier I’m crap at complaining, but when paying these relatively high prices I tend hope I don’t have a need to.
     
    What they do well, they do very well, but there are a few things they need to work on which will stop me becoming a regular visitor here.

  • http://tikichris.com tikichris

    Hi Andycop1,

    Thanks for the update! It’s a thorough review of a mixed experience and sounds like things are still about the same as when we visited a year ago when they’d just opened.

    Chris