Rail Overcrowding To Get Worse

Overcrowding on trains is set to get worse, according to a report from the Public Accounts Committee. Despite promises more than three years ago to add 1,000 carriages to trains by 2014, mostly in the south-east, it appears there will actually be 15% less space than the DfT calculates is needed just to keep overcrowding at current levels. Nice.

The problem seems to be that train operating companies (TOCs) have no incentive to add capacity – with franchises lasting less than ten years, why would they invest? – and neither do they have the power to fiddle with the timetable. Public subsidy is also being cut so no help there. The talk now is of TOCs having to become more efficient to fund improvements (anyone who commutes on the trains may want to join us in a bitter, hollow laugh at this point).

Another option put forward is flexible pricing i.e., making earlier and later trains cheaper (or making traditional commuter trains even more expensive) in the hope of shifting the burden off peak trains. But the reason a peak train is full is because, erm, we have jobs that start at 9am. Transport Secretary Philip Hammond says he’ll be unveiling plans to reduce overcrowding in the next few weeks – we wait with bated breath.

  • IanVisits

    I doubt there are many people who *have* to start work at 9am though.

    My last job had a semi-flexible starting time of 8am-10am, and equally semi-flexible ending times. As an early starter I found that I often that even if seats were all taken, there would certainly be a sensible amount of standing space.

    Likewise on the way home in the evenings, where crowding is currently more of a problem.

    Maybe if more offices sat down and worked out if they really need to start dead on 9am, and maybe introduced some flexible home working – say one or two days per week – we could reduce congestion on the networks without any real effort.

  • http://undefined Lewis

    I’m lucky enough to be able to work from home one day a week most weeks, and on other days I can get in any time up to about 10am. It’s incredible the difference between getting on a Central Line tube that arrives at Liverpool Street at 8.50am, and one arriving about 9.10am: you’re pretty much guaranteed a seat.

  • http://undefined WillBates

    I’ve started getting the train at 6.30am, yeah I have to get up early but it’s nice and peaceful. Being rammed up against multiple people (if you can even get on in the first place) is the worst way to start a day!

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/97938415@N00/ BrigadierCrispbread

    Could it be that privatisation wasn’t such a great idea after all???? I get up early and avoid the crush…going home seems more tapered…